What parts of al-Busiri's Burdah are rejected by salafis and why?
2
votes
1
answer
3226
views
Al-Burdah also known as الكواكب الدرية في مدح خير البرية is a poem of "imam al-Busiri" (the Muslim Sufi poet al-Busiri البوصيري whom studied the seerah of the prophet deeply and almost all his poems are praising the prophet()) which he wrote to praise the Prophet ().
> The Burda is divided into 10 chapters and 160 verses all rhyming with each other. ... .Each verse ends with the Arabic letter mīm, a style called mīmīya. The 10 chapters of the Burda comprise:
>
> - On Lyrical Love Yearning
> - On Warnings about the Caprices of the Self
> - On the Praise of the Prophet
> - On His Birth
> - On His Miracles
> - On the Exalted Stature and Miraculous Merits of the Qur'an
> - On the Ascension of the Prophet
> - On the Struggle of Allah's Messenger
> - On Seeking Intercession through the Prophet
> - On Intimate Discourse and the Petition of One's State.
(Source: Wikipedia )
But this poem doesn't seem to find acceptance by the salafis (like Muhammad ibn Abdulwahhab, and modern salafis such al-Albani, ibn Baz etc.). Of course mainly it is hard to say they reject the whole poem, but they surely seem to have some objections to certain parts/rhyms/words of it.
> The Burda was accepted within Sunni Islam and was the subject of numerous commentaries by mainstream Sunni scholars such as Ibn Hajar al-Haytami, Nazifi and Qastallani. It was also studied by the Shafi'i hadith master Ibn Hajar al-Asqalani (d. 852 A.H.) both by reading the text out loud to his teacher and by receiving it in writing from a transmitter who heard it directly from Busiri himself.
>
> Imam Muhammad ibn Abd al-Wahhab]], considered the poem to be shirk (idolatory).
(source Wikipedia )
Note that the hanbali scholars ibn al-'Imaad ابن العماد الحنبلي and ibn Hisham (who also was a linguist he called his "sharh": الكواكب الدرية) is one of many scholars who have written explanations and interpretations of this poem.
In many countries, this poem is well known or in the worst case a few verses of it are popular (see for example these youtube videos: Mesut Kurtis or an-Naqshabandi ). Some Muslims -mainly sufis- especially recite it/them during the Mawlid an-Nabawi.
My question is what rhymes/words/parts do salafis reject or consider as blasphemous or as words of kufr etc.? (I don't need a full list but examples of each kind of objection)
Asked by Medi1Saif
(46584 rep)
Mar 15, 2018, 09:19 AM
Last activity: Dec 6, 2023, 11:32 AM
Last activity: Dec 6, 2023, 11:32 AM