Why does the hadith "none alive today survive after one hundred years" not prove that Jesus (as) is dead?
1
vote
1
answer
862
views
From this answer: https://islam.stackexchange.com/a/79276/54227
> 19. > "None amongst the created beings would survive after one hundred years. Salim said: We made a mention of it to him (Jabir), whereupon
> he said: It means those who had been living on that day." (Sahih
> Muslim 2538e Book 44, Hadith 315)
>
> Even if Jesus (as) was alive at the time of the Holy Prophet (sa) then
> he wouldn't be 100 years after that day.
>
> There are some versions of this Hadith that use the words على ظهر
> الأرض, on the face of the earth. However, mufassirin of old such as
> Al-Alusi in Ruh-ul-Maani have used this Hadith to infer that Ilyas
> (as) and Khidr have passed away, even though Ilyas (as) is also argued
> by some to have been lifted bodily to the heavens (which is the
> context given by Al-Alusi as he mentions this hadith). So if this
> verse only applies to humans physically present on earth (and so Jesus
> (as) would be an exception) then how could mufassirin apply this verse
> to Ilyas (ra)
I want to know how do Muslims who believe Jesus (as) is alive can respond to this argument.
Asked by Zulfiqar
(11 rep)
Apr 9, 2023, 03:28 PM
Last activity: Apr 10, 2023, 02:54 PM
Last activity: Apr 10, 2023, 02:54 PM