Confusing statements regarding the hadith in At-Tirmidhi, is it hasan gharib or hasan sahih?
1
vote
1
answer
1888
views
There is a hadith narrated in At-Tirmidhi and it states that it is *hasan gharib*.
> Thawban (ra) said:
“The Messenger of Allah (ﷺ) said: ‘Whoever says when he reaches the evening: “I am pleased with Allah as (my) Lord, with Islam as (my) religion, and with Muhammad (ﷺ) as (my) Prophet (Raḍītu bi-Llāhi rabban, wa bil-Islāmi dīnan, wa bi-Muḥammadin nabiyyan) it is a duty upon Allah to please him.’” (Hasan Gharib)
But in the book of An-Nawawi (Kitab al-Adhkar - Book of Rememberances), I am reading this:
"Its isnad includes Said ibn al-Marzuban Abu Sad [...] who is considered weak[, ...] however, [He] considered this to be a *hasan sahih* hadith which is unusual in this narration; so perhaps it was *sahih* in his view from another narration."
Those are confusing statements to me, and I would like to know if there are further information or commentaries regarding this issue from other scholars?
"Its isnad includes Said ibn al-Marzuban Abu Sad [...] who is considered weak[, ...] however, [He] considered this to be a *hasan sahih* hadith which is unusual in this narration; so perhaps it was *sahih* in his view from another narration."
Those are confusing statements to me, and I would like to know if there are further information or commentaries regarding this issue from other scholars?
Asked by talibm
(916 rep)
Jul 29, 2021, 01:09 PM
Last activity: Aug 10, 2021, 09:58 AM
Last activity: Aug 10, 2021, 09:58 AM