How do proponents of the doctrine of Eternal Security explain the evidence of lifelong Christians renouncing their faith?
8
votes
3
answers
1428
views
How do advocates of *Eternal Security* explain the phenomenon of life-long Christians leaving the faith?
Here is a playlist of testimonies from former pastors: [YouTube Playlist](https://www.youtube.com/playlist?list=PLV9jojlG6VGunKZTBb8TmHfvg4ZPIjkXi)
For example:
- [Testimony of a former pastor after 30 years in ministry](https://youtu.be/e73jIl-bWuk)
- [Testimony of a former pastor after 25 years in ministry](https://youtu.be/9Q3VXwcNxcA)
- [Testimony of a former pastor after 20 years in ministry](https://youtu.be/2_A0ilgwg38)
- [Dan Barker describes going from preacher to atheist and how nature designed the world, not God](https://youtu.be/YQMascSVBDg)
Additionally, consider this [answer on Christianity StackExchange](https://christianity.stackexchange.com/a/108512/117426) , where an ex-Christian explains:
> You generally can't get a good answer to this question from people who
> haven't been through the process.
>
> I think the core reason for most of us is that we realized the
> Christian narrative is simply mythology, and cannot possibly be true.
>
> And yes, I have PLENTY of good hard evidence to back that up.
>
> Bring hurt by people in the church? A secondary reason, but often just
> an eye opener to start questioning the narrative.
>
> **Never a real Christian? Not a reason for most. Most of us who lose our**
> **faith were among the very most dedicated Christians imaginable. Our**
> **Christian experiences were just like yours if not more so. We led**
> **worship, preached, served as missionaries, wept before Jesus, spoke in**
> **tongues, gave our all, believed with our whole hearts, all of it.**
>
> Wanting to go sin? Not a reason for virtually anyone.
>
> We just loved the truth, and could no longer keep lying to ourselves
> that the Christian narrative was the truth.
Given testimonies like these, how do proponents of *Eternal Security* reconcile such evidence with their doctrine?
Asked by user117426
(654 rep)
Aug 20, 2025, 01:21 AM
Last activity: Aug 20, 2025, 03:08 PM
Last activity: Aug 20, 2025, 03:08 PM